Ask the Points Pro: Why do I board last even if I pay for seat selection?
#boarding #seat selection #airline policies #boarding groups #frequent flyer status
📌 Key Takeaways
- Seat selection fees do not affect boarding group assignments, which are determined by airline policies.
- Boarding order is typically based on fare class, frequent flyer status, or cabin, not seat selection purchases.
- Passengers may board last despite paying for seat selection if they are in a lower priority boarding group.
- Airlines prioritize boarding to streamline the process, often starting with first class and elite members.
🏷️ Themes
Airline Policies, Passenger Experience
Entity Intersection Graph
No entity connections available yet for this article.
Deep Analysis
Why It Matters
This issue affects millions of air travelers who pay extra for seat selection, only to find themselves boarding last and potentially losing overhead bin space. It highlights the growing frustration with airline ancillary fees and boarding processes that seem contradictory to customer investments. The practice impacts business travelers, families, and anyone who pays for preferred seating but then faces inconvenience during boarding, raising questions about the value proposition of these add-on purchases.
Context & Background
- Airlines have increasingly unbundled services since the 2000s, charging separately for baggage, seat selection, and other previously included amenities
- Boarding group systems became standardized in the 2010s, with most airlines using numbered groups (1-9) or zones to manage passenger flow
- Basic economy fares emerged around 2015-2017, which typically exclude seat selection and assign seats at check-in or gate
- Overhead bin space has become increasingly contested as airlines charge for checked bags, leading more passengers to carry on luggage
What Happens Next
Airlines may face increased customer complaints and potential regulatory scrutiny if this practice becomes more widespread. Some carriers might clarify their boarding policies or create exceptions for paid seat selections. Travelers will likely become more strategic about when they pay for seats versus accepting random assignments, and travel websites/forums will continue documenting these inconsistencies across different airlines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Airlines typically prioritize boarding based on fare class, elite status, and cabin, not seat selection purchases. Basic economy passengers who pay for seat selection often remain in the last boarding group because their fare type dictates boarding position, regardless of seat fees.
Overhead bin space is often limited by the time last groups board, especially on full flights. Many airlines now gate-check carry-ons for free when bins fill, but this means waiting at baggage claim and potential delays retrieving your luggage.
Policies vary by airline. Some carriers like Southwest use open seating, while others may offer earlier boarding as part of premium seat packages. Most legacy carriers maintain separate boarding priority systems that don't automatically upgrade paid seat selectors.
Seat selection guarantees where you sit on the plane, while boarding priority determines when you enter. These are typically separate purchases, with boarding priority often tied to higher fare classes, elite status, or specific boarding upgrade products.
Consider purchasing a higher fare class, achieving airline elite status through frequent flying, or buying priority boarding upgrades if available. Checking in exactly 24 hours before departure can sometimes secure better boarding positions within your assigned group.