Companies are increasingly adopting 'peanut butter' pay raises across industries
48% of organizations will continue performance-based raises while 43% are considering or implementing across-the-board increases
Experts warn this strategy could drive away top performers who feel their exceptional contributions aren't recognized
Current challenging job market may mask immediate effects, but top performers will likely leave when opportunities improve
📖 Full Retelling
Companies across various industries are increasingly implementing 'peanut butter' pay raises, according to experts warning that this cost-cutting strategy could drive away top performers, as revealed in Payscale's Pay Increase Preview Report published on February 22, 2026. The term refers to across-the-board raises that distribute compensation evenly and thinly across all employees, rather than rewarding performance differentially. While 48% of surveyed organizations plan to continue performance-based pay increases, a significant portion—9% already practicing across-the-board raises, 16% newly planning to implement the approach, and 18% considering it—suggests a growing trend toward this less merit-based compensation method. Compensation experts like Scott Hoffhines, vice president of rewards and systems at SalesLoft, warn that companies adopting this strategy are 'essentially giving up on their top talent,' potentially leading to serious morale and retention problems down the line. The trend comes amid strained compensation budgets and concerns about subjectivity and bias in performance-based evaluations, with some organizations viewing across-the-board increases as more equitable and administratively simpler to execute.
No entity connections available yet for this article.
Deep Analysis
Why It Matters
The trend of 'peanut butter' pay raises, where companies give equal, small raises to all employees regardless of performance, is a significant compensation strategy that risks demotivating top talent and leading to long-term retention problems. This approach, often driven by cost-cutting pressures and a desire for perceived fairness, can backfire when high performers feel their contributions are not being adequately rewarded. Companies may face a talent drain when the job market improves, as top performers seek employers who value their skills appropriately.
Context & Background
The term 'peanut butter' raises describes across-the-board pay increases spread thinly and evenly across all employees.
According to a Payscale report, 16% of organizations plan to newly implement this approach in 2026, while 18% are considering it.
This strategy is often adopted to cut costs, simplify administration, and address concerns about bias in performance-based raises.
The practice has been used by companies like Starbucks, which gave 2% raises to all corporate employees in 2025.
Current low hiring rates and a challenging job market make some companies feel less pressure to competitively compensate top performers.
What Happens Next
Experts predict that top performers who feel undervalued by these uniform raises will become disengaged and start looking for new jobs as the job market becomes more favorable. Companies that continue this strategy may face increased turnover and morale issues, especially among their highest-achieving employees, when economic conditions improve and mobility increases.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a 'peanut butter' pay raise?
A 'peanut butter' pay raise is an across-the-board salary increase that is the same small percentage for all employees, regardless of individual performance, spreading the budget thinly like peanut butter on bread.
Why are companies using this strategy?
Companies are using this strategy to cut costs, simplify administrative processes, avoid difficult performance conversations, and create a perception of fairness by giving everyone the same increase.
What is the main risk for companies using 'peanut butter' raises?
The main risk is demotivating and eventually losing top performers, who may feel their exceptional contributions are not being rewarded and will seek employment elsewhere when the job market improves.
}
Original Source
Related Stories Work Top 3 mistakes employees make during performance reviews—and how to avoid them Land the Job The question a PwC exec always asks to draw out a candidate's 'authentic self' Leadership Middle managers are getting cut—but their role is 'more important than ever' Work 'Fatigue' is Glassdoor's word of the year for 2025 Land the Job Top red flags job seekers should watch out for in interviews, says career expert Work ‘Peanut butter’ pay raises could cost companies their top performers, according to experts: 'It's such a shortsighted strategy' Published Sun, Feb 22 2026 10:00 AM EST Sophie Caldwell Share Share Article via Facebook Share Article via Twitter Share Article via LinkedIn Share Article via Email VIDEO 1:57 01:57 More companies are considering "peanut butter" raises Work More companies are leaning into "peanut butter" pay increases this year, according to Payscale's Pay Increase Preview Report . The term refers to across-the board raises "that are even and spread thinly, like peanut butter would be on a sandwich," according to career coach Colleen Paulson. About half — 48% — of surveyed organizations said that they will continue giving out pay increases based on performance, according to Payscale. But the report found that plenty of companies are contemplating "peanut butter" raises: Along with the 9% of organizations that already practice across-the-board pay increases, 16% said they were newly planning to implement the approach this year and 18% said they were considering it. "There's always a tension in organizations of how to how to balance the needs of your high performers while taking care of the entire group," says Scott Hoffhines, a compensation expert and the vice president of rewards and systems at SalesLoft, especially when companies have "limited resources." Still, in Hoffhines' view, companies that implement "peanut butter" raises should be aware that they are "essentially giving up on their top talent," he says — and that could l...
